Writeside.net [payal dhar's cyber den]

« A Shadow in Eternity: A review | The doomed English Patient! »

Saintly patience…

22 February 2007
Posted in: Books, Scratchpad | 7 Comments

If you have a toothache, you can take a painkiller. But if you have a bad book, you’re done for. It gnaws you from inside till you want to scream. And no matter what you do, you cannot get rid of it.

Unless you read a worse book, of course!

Well, the source of my pain is Manju Kapur’s A Married Woman. And I haven’t even finished it yet. The only reason I am soldiering on is that it makes me feel good about myself and my writing!

Reading the blurb, you’d imagine the story is mainly about a homosexual relationship between two women—one of the them the focus of the story, a “respectable” married women, mother of two. Apparently, it is a “beautifully honest and seductive story of love, set at a time of political and religious upheaval”. In truth, the book plumbs the depths of mediocrity. It is a badly executed narrative of what (so far in 200-odd pages) seems to be a pretty pointless life.

A gripping plot and a lucid narrative are perhaps the two most important ingredients of any decent book. A Married Woman has neither. A good writer can actually carry you through a bad plot, and I wish I could say that was the case here. Also, I do believe that books should make you feel. They should stir your emotions, touch you, make you laugh—oh, all right, even cry. But not cry out of frustration, or because it might hurt less to pull out your nails one by one.

Moral of the story: Next time believe a bookseller when he tells you that the book you’re buying is not worth it!

~PD

7 Responses

  1. Kat says:

    You are indeed saintly for reading what sounds like such a hideous book!

    *makes a little x with her fingers and hisses*

  2. Proteeti says:

    Jesus, Payal, whatever possessed you to buy Manju Kapur?:eek: But I must say I admire your patience – if it had been me, I would’ve consigned the book to the garbage after about 50-odd pages. It sounds awful – something like Shobhaaaaa De meets Rajkamal Jha crossed with Chetan Bhagat or something!

    And who is this kindly bookseller who actually tried to scare you away from this book?

  3. Payal says:

    Well, I paid 250 bucks for it – even after a 20 per cent discount – and I’m so going to read it! Well, you know, it’s so bad, but I just have to see where it goes!

    Oh, and it was Bookland, Janpath!

  4. Kat says:

    Is there any way you can resell it as used on ebay and make back a little bit of what you spent? 😥

  5. alpana says:

    hehehe! i read that book over a cup of tea at a book shop cum cafe in bombay. Spent 100 on the chai and snacks though. so you shouldn’t feel too bad about the 250.

  6. Payal says:

    Well, then, you’re a very bad friend for not being there to stop me when I was buying the book! 👿

  7. […] time ago I wrote about Kapur’s wholly regrettable A Married Woman. While Home doesn’t quite scrape the barrel like it, it does make you question yet again why […]

Leave a Reply

*